In M/s HDFC Property Fund v Income Tax Officer, the Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal) has, through an order dated 28 February 2019, ruled in favour of the taxpayer, a SEBI registered Venture Capital Fund (VCF) upholding its ‘pass-through’ status. The tax authorities had denied the exemption to the taxpayer on the basis that it had made investments in violation of the SEBI (Venture Capital Fund) Regulations 1996 (VCF Regulations). The Tribunal held that on fulfilment of the criteria elucidated under Section 10(23FB) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (IT Act), and in the absence of an apparent violation of SEBI regulations, the taxpayer is eligible to the exemption provided under the IT Act.
Under the IT Act, Section 10(23FB) provides an exemption for income earned by a VCF from investments in a Venture Capital Company (VCC), where such VCF: (i) operates under a trust deed, duly registered; (ii) has been granted a certificate of registration as a VCF before 21 May 2012; and (iii) is regulated by the VCF Regulations. Further, Section 115U of the IT Act provides that income arising to a person out of investments made in a VCF shall be taxed as if it were income arising to such person on account of investments made directly in the Venture Capital Undertaking (VCU). Accordingly, VCFs have been accorded a tax pass-through status in relation to investments in a VCU and the income received from such investments is taxable in the hands of the investors in the VCF.
In this case, the tax authorities challenged the tax pass-through status of M/s HDFC Property Fund (Assessee) being a SEBI registered VCF and taxed its income in the nature of capital gains and dividends etc. under the residuary head of income.
The Assessee is a trust established under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, wherein Housing Development Finance Corporation Limited, in its capacity as settlor, had identified investment opportunities in high-growth sectors, including real estate. In furtherance of these investment opportunities, the Assessee was established as a VCF and was registered with the SEBI under the VCF Regulations.
For the relevant year (2013-14), the Assessee, inter alia, earned income from investments in VCUs and sought an exemption under Section 10(23FB) as well as Section 10(35) for dividend income from units of mutual funds.
The tax authorities were of the view that the investments made in: (a) units of mutual funds; and (b) debenture application money (towards optionally convertible debentures), did not qualify as investments in VCUs and were therefore, in violation of the trust deed as well as the VCF Regulations. Accordingly, the Assessee was considered non-compliant with conditions prescribed for a VCF and was denied exemption under Section 10(23FB).
The Tribunal rejected the contention of the tax authorities and held that the Assessee is eligible to exemption under Section 10(23FB) based on the following key observations:
This is a welcome ruling where the Tribunal has examined the issue in light of the relevant provisions of the IT Act, applicable SEBI regulations, informal guidance issued by the SEBI as well as the industry practice.
In this case, the taxpayer was registered as a VCF and was governed by the VCF Regulations, which have now been repealed and replaced by the SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012 (AIF Regulations). Investment funds are now registered as Alternate Investment Funds (AIF) under the AIF Regulations, which also enjoy a tax pass through status so long as they are registered as Category I or II funds. Thus, the ruling will continue to have significance for the funds industry.
The case does leave one question open vis-à-vis the jurisdiction of the tax authorities to determine compliance with other laws. The taxpayer did raise a specific objection as to whether it is within the domain of the tax authorities to determine infraction with other laws, however, the Tribunal has not dealt with this question.
- Bijal Ajinkya (Partner), Ritu Shaktawat (Partner) and Srishti Mukherjee (Associate)
For any queries please contact: firstname.lastname@example.org